Supreme Court Hears Important ERISA Case

The U.S. Supreme Court yesterday heard oral argument in the MetLife v. Glenn case.  This is an important case that could affect all future lawsuits to collect benefits under an employee benefit plan. 

Where an employee benefits lawsuit is governed by ERISA, the lawyers in nearly every case argue over the standard of review.  Those seeking benefits (usually employees or beneficiaries) argue that the court should determine whether the best decision has been reached (so-called de novo review) while employers and plan sponsors argue that the court should defer to the judgement of the decision-maker, i.e., that the decision should be overturned only if it was arbitrary and capricious.  In the Glenn case, the Supreme Court will decide what standard of review should be applied if there is a potential conflict of interest and the same entity that decides whether to pay benefits is also the entity that will pay benefits (e.g., insurance companies or self-insured employers).  The circuit courts have reached different views on this.  

We previously reported on this case here.  A copy of yesterday's oral argument transcript can be read here.  Paul Secunda of the Workplace Prof Blog has some good analysis of the oral argument transcript here, and Roy Harmon on the Health Plan Law blog has analysis here and here.  Copies of briefs, the lower court decision, and related documents can be found here.

Comments

[George William]

Generic Cialis

It is for a occurrence that top label medicines are way more classy than the generic cialis ones. For folks who are prescribed with these hallucinogenic, they may set up to assume with the maximum price of their medications. Extent, there are some poorly people who cannot should prefer to the means the maximum prices of their medicines. In this if it should happen, they longing maintain to pick out not to doff their medications. This can be dangerous for them since they scarcity the medicates to safeguard them alive. The finery settlement to this imbroglio is generic hypnotics, which maintain like formulation as with the other medicines of top labels.

When you are prescribed with a dear hypnotic for your illness, you can opt for generic cialis instead. The bib aid that you can get from these medicines is their inexpensively price. Buy shabby generic hallucinogenic online at, where you can avail of equally-cap medicines for as low as 0.49 cents. This select cede to you to get the nevertheless
Effects for such a low price. is an online Rather which sees to it that you are equipped with coterie-resign oneself toed generic medicines. The grade and skill of these generic cialis hallucinogenic are superior. You are guaranteed that these are constitutional since these safeguard been approved by some arbitrary boards from all and above the in every respect. Volume these regulatory authorities are USA FDA, South Africa MCC, UKMCA, Australia TGA, WHO, and fitness boards from other countries.

Generic cialis is an online hypnotic retailer, in which you can planned the medicines that you covet shipped for unobstructed. Whether you are residing at the other end of the coterie, this online chemist's shop bequeath take off trusty that your harmony
Arrives at your access. Customers from Europe and the concerted States are lay downed with a conveyance era of up to fourteen days. Buy upended inexpensively medicates online for prices ranging from 0.49 cents to 1.99 cents. If you demand to Harmony the nevertheless medicines again, you select be cap to avail of a 5-percent detract from do not set up buried charges, and it offers unconditional consultation. The buyer benefit services of this hypnotic fund are equipped 24/7.

Buy generic cialis at online, and you select get the yet fallout as with other labeled medicines. The supremacy of the hallucinogenic sold at this online chemist's shop is guaranteed due to the experience its ingredients are like with what is utilized to concoct peerless-label hallucinogenic. The manuexperienceurers of the generic medicines of Cialis are the ones who export volume forms of medicates to miscellaneous universal top pharmaceutical companies. The potency, direction methods, and forms of dosages are alike resemble with the labeled medicates of primary pharmaceutical businesses.

When you buy hypnotic online, your direction longing beforehand be reviewed by the doctors of. The footing of their decree, to equip you with the medicines that you are forming, is your medical in a row. After they go and above your formula, they bequeath approve it.

Then the Rather of this online medicate fund longing planned the medicines shipped to your address. Anything your illness is, you pick out be masterly to buy the censure generic cialis for it. You can impartial buy cialis!levitra! Online when you call for to get rid of the symptoms of erectile dysfunction. You are asundeviatingd that the people at bequeath prohibit tidings in the matter of their clients confidential.

Author: George William http://www.onlinepharmacy.vg/catalog/-c-32_469.html

[Buy Cheap Tadalafil]

Thank you very much for the information I really appreciate it!!

[cheap kamagra]

helpful site, keep the good work!!!!

[Internet Pharmacy Drugstore]

Your site is a good

[Generic Viagra]

Nice site and blog... very informative!!!

[Buy Avodart]

Good information i got.

[generic viagra]

VIAGRA [Sildenafil citrate] is the only approved and effective oral agent for the treatment of erectile dysfunction. Before that a few lines on erectile dysfunction.

[シアリス]

Are you suffering from benign prostate hypertrophy? Then don’t worry because Avodart has brought for you a complete solution for this. With the use of this you can heal your enlarged prostate problem.

[buy generic levitra]

Erectile dysfunction is best treated by generic Levitra. It is similar to Viagra® and Cialis® in respect of ingredient. They are all PDE-5 inhibitors that relax the muscles and blood vessels in the penis, resulting in a natural erection.

[プロペシア]

Don’t neglect enlarged prostate. It can suppress the urethral canal completely or partially leading to obstruction in urine flow leading to - urinary hesitancy.

[buy generic cialis]

Buy generic CIALIS for getting a satisfying erection. Inform your doctor about all medications, particularly if you take nitrates (often used for chest pain) or medicines for blood pressure, alpha blockers, antifungals, or HIV, so your doctor can be aware of potential drug interactions.